Midtown-Times Square · Bar · $$$
Polly's NYC
Speakeasy downstairs next to Tanner Smith's. Banana bread martini, brisket nachos, solid wine — pricey but the drinks and decor justify it.
Best for
Plan a night around it →
We'll start the night in its neighborhood and build the rest.
Similar spots nearby
- Madame GeorgeMidtown-Times Square · Bar · $$$Speakeasy setup: fluorescent stairwell descent, velvet booths, live music weekends. Bartenders who actually talk to you — ask for the non-sweet stuff.
- Rosevale Cocktail RoomHell's Kitchen · Bar · $$$Live jazz weekends, cocktails with care, upscale but not stuffy — Hell's Kitchen spot that gets the balance right.
- The Woo WooMidtown-Times Square · Bar · $$Ring the bell, give the password, step into an 80s fever dream. Photo booth, creative cocktails, nacho fries that don't disappoint.